The Swinsian Switch
posted 2 hours ago #
I realize how archaic this makes me but I still maintain a local library of Music. I am also a YouTube Music subscriber but I have a lot of purchased music that often lives outside of streaming and I need a way to enjoy it. Up until recently I have been an iTunes user; somewhat begrudingly but it worked well enough. Until it didn't. Once it switched from being iTunes to "Music" the app just slowly fell apart. Most recently, it just wouldn't make playlists anymore. Except it is making playlists, it's just not updating the side drawer to show them. I ended up trying a myriad of fixes to overcome this, even going as far as formatting an old ExFat drive to the preferred APFS; hoping it was a weird external drive + permissions error. Turns out, it's a known bug and Apple just hasn't gotten around to it yet. Enshittification comes for everything.
In my quest to find an alternative, many people suggested Navidrome or Plexamp. Both look great but both require a permanently connected drive, which is not my use case. I have an SSD drive that is only occasionally connected, so I need something less network based. I landed on Swinsian, a robust music player that seems to take on the job of being a proper iTunes replacement.
My positive review is that it is incredibly fast, handles metadata unbelievably quickly and can present a giant library of music efficiently. It can make new playlists and actually show them. From a simple perspective of music organization and playback, it's checking all the boxes. It's also maintaining the same file structure as iTunes and can export to an XML format that is easy to import back into Music, so you're not locked into a proprietary format.
In an ideal world, it would have a little more visual personality. I found its plainness a little off-putting at first but the more I use it, the more I like it. It's also a little concerning that the blog hasn't been updated in a year but, hey, who has time to blog, amirite?
Long story short, I think I've finally abandoned ship on iTunes and have found a worthwhile alternative. This may inspire me to figure out a network connected solution tho... this single SSD drive with my lifetime library on it is maybe a little precarious!
In my quest to find an alternative, many people suggested Navidrome or Plexamp. Both look great but both require a permanently connected drive, which is not my use case. I have an SSD drive that is only occasionally connected, so I need something less network based. I landed on Swinsian, a robust music player that seems to take on the job of being a proper iTunes replacement.
My positive review is that it is incredibly fast, handles metadata unbelievably quickly and can present a giant library of music efficiently. It can make new playlists and actually show them. From a simple perspective of music organization and playback, it's checking all the boxes. It's also maintaining the same file structure as iTunes and can export to an XML format that is easy to import back into Music, so you're not locked into a proprietary format.
In an ideal world, it would have a little more visual personality. I found its plainness a little off-putting at first but the more I use it, the more I like it. It's also a little concerning that the blog hasn't been updated in a year but, hey, who has time to blog, amirite?
Long story short, I think I've finally abandoned ship on iTunes and have found a worthwhile alternative. This may inspire me to figure out a network connected solution tho... this single SSD drive with my lifetime library on it is maybe a little precarious!




















